Each Holstein on Dennis
Haubenschild's dairy farm chomps down 90 pounds of feed, yields eight
gallons of milk, and produces 220 pounds of manure (including the
shredded newspaper bedding) - daily. It's a pretty standard operation
in the dairy industry.
But his 750 cows are also in another business with a different
product line: Every one of the half-ton beasts generates 4 kilowatt
hours of electricity a day.
Locals call it "cow power," and it keeps the lights
burning and supper warm in 75 rural Minnesota homes north of
Minneapolis.
The cow-to-electricity operation on Mr. Haubenschild's farm is part
of a born-again interest in putting to good use a problematic
farm-waste product - that is, gigantic loads of manure. While overall
investment in such "waste-to-energy" efforts is small, in
the range of $20 million, interest is higher today than at any point
since the 1980s, say enthusiasts.
For Haubenschild, the benefits are numerous. The manure is
contained in a covered pit, so his downwind neighbors can smell the
daisies instead of nose-stinging cow excrement. The pit is
cement-lined, so the waste won't seep into the groundwater or run off
into rivers and streams. The methane gas that is produced as the
manure decomposes is channeled into use as a renewable energy source,
rather than dispersing into the atmosphere, where it would contribute
to global warming. What's more, his cows generated $81,000 worth of
electricity last year, helping to keep the farm in the black during
times of low milk prices.
If it's such a brilliant solution, what took so long?
The answer, as is often the case in localized energy projects, is
money. Dairy farms already operate close to the margin, and finding
the dollars for the initial investment is no easy matter.
Methane-fired electricity generators don't come cheap, and they need
to be individually designed (bring on the engineering consultants) to
fit the circumstances of each farm.
A harmonic convergence
Haubenschild, who has been interested in this renewable technology
since the 1970s, finally saw his opportunity in the late 1990s - and
seized it. The US Environmental Protection Agency was increasingly
concerned about methane gas (a greenhouse gas 21 times as potent as
carbon dioxide), and Minnesota agriculture officials, meanwhile, were
fretting over declining farm incomes. With a patchwork of state and
federal grants, and with help from the University of Minnesota and a
nonprofit group called the Minnesota Project, Haubenschild was able to
build a $350,000 electricity-generating plant on his 1,000-acre farm.
His idea was that the plant would demonstrate that his dream of
electricity from manure was feasible.
He was right.
"I had no doubt that it would work," Haubenschild says.
"It just took quite a few years to tie everything together."
When Haubenschild's system was completed in 1999, his was one of
only 31 electricity-generating methane harvesters on US farms. But its
success exceeded even the engineers' expectations, and published
reports about its merits are reviving interest in the technology.
"As of spring 2002, there were over 40 digester systems in
operation at livestock farms in the United States, with dozens more in
the planning stage," the Minnesota Project wrote in its August
report on Haubenschild's generator.
One man who was not surprised by the results is Dick Waybright of
Mason Dixon Farms, near Gettysburg, Pa. He has used a similar system
for more than two decades.
It is an "important part of our profit picture. We get 30
percent or better annual return on our investment," says Mr.
Waybright, who milks 2,150 cows with his sons.
Mason Dixon Farms' methane-to- energy system was part of a wave of
such projects built in the 1970s and '80s. But Waybright's experience
was not the norm. Often, systems built during that time failed because
of poor engineering or poor construction. Ultimately, bad publicity
snuffed out further interest.
But the dream of profits from manure persisted in the minds of
inventive farmers like Haubenschild and engineers interested in
renewable energy. The Haubenschild system is part of a trend toward
on-farm energy production.
So, how does it work?
The Haubenschild design begins, plainly enough, with a
350,000-gallon cement pit full of manure. The pit is also heated. And
it has an inflatable, snow-white fabric cover that keeps heat (and
odor) in and oxygen out.
Mark Mosser of Resource Conservation Management of Berkeley,
Calif., the firm that designed the cow-to-electricity system, likens
it to a giant tube of toothpaste open on both ends.
"Today's manure enters the tube and pushes yesterday's manure
forward," he said during a farm tour.
The manure spends two to three weeks in the pit. There, it is
introduced to anaerobic, or oxygen-hating, bacteria, a process that
emits methane. Engineers have a polite term for the pit and its
contents: a methane digester.
"The methane flows up and out the pit into pipes, where it's
metered into the generator engine," Mosser says. The engine, in
short, burns methane gas to make electricity. The electricity is
sufficient to power both the Haubenschild farm and nearby homes.
Before the manure enters the pit, it slides down a series of pipes
into a vat that the engineer likens to a large milkshake mixer. There,
a milkshake-consistency slurry of manure and shredded-newspaper cow
bedding is prepared for the hungry bacteria.
One reason for the system's surprisingly efficient performance is
the cellulose-rich newspaper. Anaerobic bacteria prefer newspaper
shakes to those made from straw bedding.
"We use a thousand pounds a day," says Bryan
Haubenschild, Dennis's son. "We get it free from a local
publisher."
The methane-fired engine itself also produces "waste" -
in the form of heat. That waste heat is used to warm large tanks of
water, and the water, in turn, is used to heat the barn. That replaced
$4,000 worth of propane.
The key to converting all these waste products to electricity is to
sell the electricity profitably. Haubenschild sells his to the local
utility for 7.3 cents per kilowatt hour. That happens to be the retail
rate that the utility charges for a farm his size.
"This project is an opportunity to make use of renewable
energy and promote sustainable agriculture," says Henry Fisher of
East Central Energy. "We roll the energy into our 'green power'
program, where we can charge a premium over the retail rate to cover
distribution costs." Despite the higher cost, ratepayers have
signed on to use all the "green" power the utility has to
offer. It's a testament to the marketing appeal of what East Central
Energy calls cow power.
In addition to being popular with customers, profitable for
farmers, and friendly to the environment, the cow power generator has
operated with a high degree of reliability.
"Haubenschild Farms has operated the generator at over 95
percent availability," wrote Carl Nelson and John Lamb, authors
of the Minnesota Project report. "This far exceeds even the
highest-performing coal plants."
One drawback with cow-to-electricity systems, says Mr. Nelson, is
that they operate efficiently only on farms with 400 or more cows.
That's six or seven times the average size of a Minnesota dairy herd.
"We'd like to see design and engineering that would make these
systems feasible on smaller farms," he says.